Shelter Island
This seaside haven is home to a tight-knit community of summertime guests and permanent residents.
Welcome to Shelter Island
Secluded tranquility in a residential paradise.
Just a five-minute ferry ride from the mainland, Shelter Island is one of the Hamptons’ most beloved spots for relaxation. Shelter Island, though a bit of a different atmosphere than the rest of the Hamptons, shares similar beauty. Decorated throughout the island are gorgeous flowers such as hydrangeas and tulips. Beautiful blue waves crash onto unspoiled, sandy beaches and can be viewed from almost anywhere on this 8,000-acre island.
This seaside haven is home to a tight-knit community of summertime guests and permanent residents. Shelter Island is quieter in the summer than other Hampton communities — a factor appealing to many seeking a laid-back community near the water.
Varying home styles are found on Shelter Island. Oceanfront cottages are prevalent in the area, with shuttered roofs and spacious porches overlooking the water. Colonial and Greek Revival styles also dominate the island, and their impressive columns, symmetrical exterior, and grand, old-world charm can be seen in Shelter Island’s tranquil residential areas.
What to Love
The natural beauty throughout the island
The wide array of water recreation, from kayaking to paddle boarding
Picture-perfect beaches
Quick ferry rides to the mainland for retail, dining, and entertainment offerings
The relaxing atmosphere reminiscent of a permanent vacation
Local Lifestyle
Life on Shelter Island is unrefined elegance. Though Shelter Island is known for its beautiful simplicity, it also offers a jaw-dropping selection of upmarket boutiques, lavish restaurants, and pristine green spaces. Relaxing on the beach or sunbathing on a prized yacht is the norm here, and residents wouldn’t have it any other way.
Locals enjoy exploring their community. Paddleboarding, kayaking, surfing, swimming, and boating are popular aquatic sports here. The island also boasts many hiking, biking, and walking trails.
Dining, Shopping & Entertainment
There are many top-rated restaurants to dine at while on Shelter Island. 18 Bay serves fresh Italian dishes in a picturesque Victorian house. Ingredients come from local markets in the East End of Long Island. Vine Street Café is a charming restaurant that delights guests with its classic American cuisine. Its cottage location provides a rustic, warm, and romantic dining experience.
Léon 1909 is an upscale restaurant serving Italian and French fare and is the perfect spot for a romantic date night or brunch with friends and family. SALT Waterfront Bar & Grill is one of the Hamptons’ most popular seafood restaurants. Open seasonally, this oceanfront locale has both indoor and outdoor seating areas, including a large deck overlooking the water.
Things to Do
Golf enthusiasts tee off at the Shelter Island Country Club, an iconic, nine-hole golf course open to the public. After a long day on the green, head to the clubhouse, where you can enjoy an on-site restaurant serving lunch and dinner during peak months. The club also hosts a junior golf program and the Hickory Golf Classic.
Spending quality time in Mother Nature has never been easier than at the Mashomack Preserve, whose eleven miles of coastline are home to numerous habitats. Wind your way along the preserve’s well-kept trail to catch a glimpse of the animals that live on the island.
Dive into Shelter Island’s past at the Shelter Island Historical Society. This venue offers exhibits from Native American inhabitants and an awe-inspiring collection of historical artwork. The East End Seaport Museum and Marine Foundation, located in neighboring Greenport, is just a short commute from the historical society. Here, guests will discover exhibits displaying facts about ocean life, take a lighthouse cruise, get a first-hand glimpse of marine animals at the on-site aquarium, or attend the Maritime Festival.
Overview for Shelter Island, NY
2,499 people live in Shelter Island, where the median age is 42.9 and the average individual income is $56,486. Data provided by the U.S. Census Bureau
2,499
Total Population
42.9 years
Median Age
Low
Population Density
$56,486
Average individual Income
Demographics and Employment Data for Shelter Island, NY
2,499 people call Shelter Island home. The population density is 381.3 and the largest age group is between 25 and 64 years old. Data provided by the U.S. Census Bureau.
2,499
Total Population
Low
Population Density
42.9
Median Age
57.46 / 42.54%
Men vs Women
Population by Age Group
Education Level
- Less Than 9th Grade
58 (4%)
- High School Degree
379 (24%)
- Associate Degree
59 (4%)
- Bachelor Degree
550 (35%)
- Graduate Degree
515 (33%)
Shelter Island has 1,084 households, with an average household size of 2.31. Data provided by the U.S. Census Bureau.
1,084
Total Households
2.31
Average Household Size
$56,486
Average individual Income
Here’s what the people living in Shelter Island do for work — and how long it takes them to get there. Data provided by the U.S. Census Bureau.
Schools in Shelter Island, NY
The following schools are within or nearby Shelter Island. The rating and statistics can serve as a starting point to make baseline comparisons on the right schools for your family. Data provided by the U.S. Census Bureau.
TYPE
NAME
NAME
Shelter Island School
33 N Ferry Rd, Shelter Island, NY, 11964
Work With Us
We pride ourselves in providing personalized solutions that bring our clients closer to their dream properties and enhance their long-term wealth.
